CASE STUDY

Longfellow Apartments: Pricing a Rent-Control Exemption

Deal Close

August 28, 2026

Type

Multifamily, 23 units

Price

$3,175,000

Michael Murray
Mid-Atlantic Multifamily Team

Executive Summary

Longfellow closed out a three-property portfolio disposition for a longtime client, a retired attorney.

The asset itself was ordinary Class B/C product, but it happened to be exempt from DC’s rent control ordinance — adistinction Greysteel priced deliberately, closing at roughly a 5.75% cap on trailing-12-month income against a market running closer to 7% for comparable rent-controlled buildings.

The Challenge

Comparable Class B/C multifamily in DC was trading in the high-6% to 7% cap rate range. Making the case for a materially tighter cap required convincing buyers the rent-control exemption was worth the premium.

The Solution

Greysteel positioned the asset around its rent-growth potential and the operational flexibility that comes with no rent cap, rather than letting it get priced against restricted comparables by default.

Results

  • $3,175,000 sale price at approximately a 5.75% cap rate on T12 income
  • Roughly 125 basis points tighter than prevailing cap rates on comparable rent-controlled Class B/C product
  • Closed out a long-standing client’s three-property portfolio disposition

“The rent-control-exempt asset commanded a premium relative to comparable Class B/C product, closing at approximately a 5.75% cap rate on T12. Greysteel positioned the property around its stronger rent-growth potential and greater operational flexibility, helping deliver pricing well above prevailing cap rates for similar older multifamily assets.” — Michael Murray, Greysteel Lead Deal Contact, Mid-Atlantic Multifamily Team

Greysteel Advisory Expertise

Greysteel is a commercial real estate advisory firm specializing in investment sales and debt and structured finance, serving private investors, middle-market operators, and institutional clients nationwide.

The firm provides sector-focused advisory across multifamily, healthcare, and affordable housing and other commercial real estate asset classes, delivering market intelligence, capital markets expertise, and disciplined execution.